Monday, July 25, 2005

An Hour With Leon


So, I tuned in for the first hour of the Leon Gray Show this afternoon. It was... well, OK. I expected something different somehow. It was any other talk show, but with different carpet, furniture and paint.

The topic of the day was local: the renaming of Memphis parks. Leon called Nathan Forrest a "terrorist" guilty of "treason," saying he lived under the same Constitution we do today. Of course, that's silly; he didn't. Grey seems to have no understanding of the nation at that time, nor the people and culture of the era. His grasp of history and historical context were pretty woeful, almost embarrassing.

Leon went to the phones pretty quickly, no long-winded monologue after the introductory thank-yous and hellos. He was good about letting callers have their say, but a couple of times had to hurry people along as the breaks came up. They seemed to be spaced about 10 minutes apart. He didn't have much in the way of paying ads -- a lot of promos, "Memphis urban legends," and public service stuff by and large. I'm guessing that when the first Arbitron numbers come out, you'll see an increase in paying ads.

Of course, they played a eulogy to Fleming that was "heh" funny, but not "ahahahahahahaha" funny.

Then Harold Ford Jr called in about 4:45. Everything went out the window and Gray spend the rest of the hour with the erstwhile Senator-wannabe. He even got Ford to state unequivocally that he's really, truly, no second thoughts running for Senator Frist's seat. Sheesh, why is that an issue?

The Congressman blathered about his opposition to the PATRIOT act and the requisite grilling of Judge Roberts for the Supreme Court nomination. As it says in my notes: "blahblahblah."

The choice of bumper music was telling: Sixties/Seventies nostalgia! BTO and Takin' Care of Business, Sam and Dave's Soul Man, Money, Hear it Through the Grapevine, Spirit in the Sky. Boomer nostalgia.

It wasn't a mess, though there were glitches, but it wasn't compelling radio, either. I'll listen out the week. If something merits more notice, I'll pass it on.
Ford Question


Haorld Ford was otherwise occupied Saturday and didn't attend the Shelby County Democratic Party convention. His official schedule lists no public event. Anyone know what was more important for him than securing his base? Nothing sinister here (yeah, yeah), just curious.
I Wanna Know


So, did anyone make it out Friday to hear Mr. Jon Sparks in his musical performance debut? How was it? Did glass break or little children run away? Women swoon? Pictures?
I Have a Dream Now


The other Chris, the Pesky Fly at The Flypaper Theory, eviscerates a Wendi Thomas column. Of course, this is like saying a chef filets a fish or a golfer putts the ball, but there you are.

FlyGuy quotes Thomas:
Not all dreams are worth dreaming.
Oh, I don't know. I've always wanted to be a dim, sniffy, shallow, light-weight, selfish, moralistic columnist who gets by with easy, surface-skating stances on hot-button issues instead of having to dig deeper and think harder than the average person (or the below-average person, come to think of it). And with Wendi, I have a role model!

On the other hand, I really do hate giving this kid any mention. I'm very sure that, like Mike Fleming, she regards all press as good press and all the controversy over what she writes as just the mindless chatter of the less-important hoi polloi.

She sounds, in that waste of column inches, like the Convention and Visitor's Bureau shill she is. Likely her boss and his "friends" like that just fine.
Dr. Abby's Bye-Bye Bloggers Bash


It's on! We get to meet Dr. Abby's parents and say good bye to her and Aaron. It will be at Dish, in Cooper-Young, starting around 6PM. Details as they evolve at Adventures with Dr. Lady Cutie Troublemaker.

These bashes are purely social occasions. If you've ever thought of coming but held off, fear not! Lots of fun, lots of nice people. Please spread the word on your own blogs.
Cameron Responds


Remember the incident I blogged about last week, involving WPTY/24 anchor Cameron Harper calling someone a "fool" and a "chump" during a newscast?

Well, Cameron comments today on his blog. He admirably tells of standing up for WPTY reporter Craig Bell, as News Director Jim Turpin did for him in the "Mayor, will you resign?" kerfuffle earlier this year, but doesn't really get into why he did it the way he did. Yes, holding feet to the fire is great, but calling names a bit less so.

I was also surprised to learn how scripted it was (at least in the 9PM broadcast). That takes a bit of the luster off. Still and all, it's good to see some of the human behind the television masks.
Is It Too Far Yet?


The Lt. Governor of Pennsylvania shows up at a family funeral, passing out her business cards and trying to make an anti-war point. She misjudged, badly, and is now being asked to resign. Mark at the Conservative Zone has more on dumb politicians.

Chris Muir's Day by Day cartoon has something to add.
A Belated Thought


It's something I've noticed for several years but it only just this morning clicked in my head and gelled into a concrete thought.

The City of Memphis fireworks display on July 4 is emblematic of City Hall's downtown-centric attitude.

Every year I like to watch fireworks on the Fourth. Where I live in Midtown I have a clear view right to the downtown and the river where the fireworks go off. Only problem is, they are aimed too low. If I'm lucky I can just see the tops of the really big Chrysanthemum Blossoms or whatever. I can hear it all quite well -- humid summer air carries the bump-pop-pop-pop quite well -- but even though the fireworks are aimed right over the Mississippi, they happen really close to the water's surface.

I'm sure someone has a perfectly good and reasonable explanation, like wanting them low to really impress the crowds. But so what? It's the City of Memphis Fireworks Display! What's wrong with letting the whole city see it?

When I lived in Birmingham, Alabama, the annual fireworks show was held from Vulcan Park atop Red Mountain. Red Mountain is an enormous lump of iron and clay sticking out of the flat ground of the City of Birmingham. It's the final outpost of the Appalachian Mountains before you get to the Mississippi Delta and the Alabama Wiregrass. Rather than hold the fireworks display in some football stadium or city park, it's put waaay up on top of Red Mountain, where everyone and their cousin can see it for miles around.

I lived in the shadow of the Vulcan statue. Walk out the front door, look up and behind you to the left and there he is on his lonely vigil. On the Fourth, floods of people would still come to the neighborhood to be right under the explosions, to feel them as well as hear them. My neighbors with the powerhouse stereo would crank up the radio simulcast until they got bored, then they'd play disco or R&B for the rest of the night. It was great community fun.

So why can't the City of Memphis loft our fireworks up where the whole city can enjoy? Yeah, I know, we don't have a mountain; we have a river. Still, that only means there's nothing flammable underneath to worry about!

So, why? Because it's all for the benefit of the folks downtown, on the RiverBluff, the RiverMark and on Mud Island and in all those rabbit warrens called apartment communities. Want to see it? Sure, come on downtown. Fight the traffic, the crowds, the drunks, the pickpockets, the parking, the waits. Come downtown! Maybe spend some bucks in Peabody Plaza or on Beale Street while you're stuck there. (Stay off the Main Street Mall, though. It's a bit dangerous.)

But share it with the rest of you? No, no, no. There's no money in that.

Sunday, July 24, 2005

Chris, Chris, Chris


The Commercial Appeal's Editor in Chief, Chris Peck, launched a salvo against press critics Sunday. But what it says about him and his paper is enlightening. Let's delve:
You've heard about media bias.

A day doesn't pass without some critic complaining about his or her treatment in the media.
So, it's personal is it? Not a legitimate criticism, but a "complaint?" Already, the buck is in hand, the pass soon to come.
In the news business, editors routinely must cope with those who see gay or anti-gay bias; pro-Bush or anti-Bush bias; support-the-war or anti-war bias; pro-business or anti-business bias. The list could go on.
Note that he's talking political bias right now. Remember that.

Isn't it interesting what pops into his mind when he has to find examples. Although the sides fall both ways, it's always "anti"-this or that. The two topics he chose that don't rate a modifying "support" clause are gays and the War on Terror. I'm not sure what all this means, but it hints at something fun.
After 30 years of working in news organizations, I worry about bias, too.

But from inside the news business, my concerns look different from what I hear on talk radio or from the guy on the street.
Notice who the critics are now: "Talk radio or... the guy on the street." See how's he's subtly begun to shift the topic, from the concerns of readers about coverage bias to his concerns as a newsman.
For example, I don't think media bias is about some liberal agenda. That's too simple and too easy to fix.
And yet the criticisms continue. Why is that? The shift continues, as we see. He's now narrowed it down from "pro-this or anti-that" to an accusation of liberal agenda.

It is easy to fix. Hire more diversity of viewpoint in the newsroom. Studies still show the overwhelming liberal political bias of reporters and editors. If you're surrounded by folks who think like you, do you really believe they'll offer dissenting or unheard points of view? Or will they reinforce the prevailing point of view?
In most newspaper and television newsrooms, reporters and editors routinely hunt for political spin. A discipline journalists learn early on is the ability to wring out loaded words, one-sided accounts and blatant examples of political grandstanding. Yeah, sometimes reporters get taken in and their editors are asleep at the switch. Far more often, however, the spin of liberal or conservative tone gets edited out.
Ahh.... But if everyone agrees in the newsroom that something is a bad thing, will they see the "anti-bad thing" bias in an article written about it? Or will it sound just right to them?

Peck is being disingenuous anyway. One of the things the blogosphere (notice he hasn't mentioned any of them yet?) has done is to point out the routine examples of just the kind of errors Peck lists above. Time and time again, in papers large and small all over the country. For heaven's sake, how does Peck square CBS' and Dan Rather's massive failure over the Texas National Guard story?

Peck sounds too much like the Catholic priest reassuring the flock that the incident with the new priest from the faraway parish was an isolated one with no precedent and no chance of being repeated.
Nor is media bias about journalists being anti-American. I don't buy that criticism, even in this time of war.

The very foundation of our constitutionally protected right of free speech and a free press comes from an understanding that the media can, indeed must, be skeptical and critical of government and politicians, even during national crises. That's what keeps people honest, even as those in power protest that the media aren't with the program.
Wow, what a loaded paragraph! So, the War on Terror is a "national crisis?"

What "keeps people honest" is a fear of consequences. That's been one of the goods of the blogosphere, keeping newspapers' feet to the fire of public exposure for lapses of fact and abuse of position.

It's a topic way to large to discuss well here, but let's touch briefly on reporters and freedom of speech. That freedom comes from the limits placed on government by the Constitution of the United States, Amended. That freedom is intrinsically and uniquely American. The British, Canadian and Australian press can all be muzzled by the government, with suitable reason.

So, when folks like Peck wave the First Amendment around, it's hard to square how they can then approach international affairs with the same neutrality they impose on domestic coverage. To place other nations' actions against us on the same level as American actions, to take no America-centric position but to abrogate their Americanness is to repudiate the nation and the lives that bought that freedom for them.

There is also the fact that what the nation's local papers report about international news comes from a mere handful of people working for a mere handful of news organisations. The Commercial Appeal routinely lets the writers of the New York Times, Reuters and the Washington Post do their international news reporting. Anything those reporters introduce into their coverage gets picked up by and carried in hundreds of smaller papars around the nation.

There is no question that that coverage is concerned with "what went wrong" or "who got hurt" -- the standard definitions of news. Explosions and bombings always get reported; not so for the rebuilding of schools and power plants and hospitals. The Memphis Flyer, to my knowledge, has written exactly one story on West Tennessee soldiers fighting in Iraq. Writer Chris Davis went scouring North-central Tennessee to find a disgruntled soldier, while passing hundreds who weren't. Is this bias?
The media are part of the program. It's just that our part is to ask questions and seek truths. If anything, more media skepticism about the push to war in Iraq might have helped our nation be better informed about the need for the war and better understand what it will cost for the nation to prevail in the Mideast.
There is a huge difference between skepticism and reflexive opposition. Too much of the national press is reflexively opposed to whatever they are told, regardless of reason or common sense.

But this is all national stuff, which the Commercial Appeal doesn't do itself, relying on a handful of national newspapers to do it for them. Do they question the people who hand this stuff to them? Are they skeptical of what they are presented? Somehow, given Peck's faith in the power of the media to police itself, as he noted above, I doubt it.

Does his Commercial Appeal approach local issues with this kind of skepticism? It doesn't often seem that way, especially in his new, local editions, where stories are printed that are written by the companies, businesses, etc. themselves, and not by skeptical CA reporters. Or take the FedEx Forum, for example. It's the biggest public expenditure in Memphis history. Does the Commercial Appeal approach its operation and funding skeptically? Not on the evidence. They seem rather credulous of what they are told by the Mayor and the people who run it and the Grizzlies.
I'm concerned about a different kind of bias I see creeping into news.
After long disquisition on reader perceptions of political bias, wherein he proves its unwarranted, Peck now shifts to what he really wants to talk about.
I've heard it described as informational bias. It's a big challenge.

Here's an example of how it creeps into the work of newspapers, TV stations and online media.
Notice how he suddenly wants to include the onlne and television news media? If you read his paper, it has a disturbing and myopic talent for pretending there is no other source of news in the city. Stories originated in television news will never find the station involved identified. I like to call it "competition bias" but that's just me. See, I can invent a distracting bias just like Chris!
A story a few days ago quoted the new head of the National Academy of Sciences saying that global warming is caused by human beings and their modern, fossil fuel-driven lifestyles.

Ralph Cicerone is a renowned expert on climate change. He knows what he's talking about. His views reflect the overwhelming majority of scientific thought and research on global climate change. By burning tons of coal to make electricity and driving millions of automobiles that emit gases, we're causing the world's climate to change.

Standing against this record of the human causes of global climate change are some political forces in Washington who continue to say that we need more research and that the record is unclear about whether human activity is causing increases in the greenhouse gases that lead to global warming.
Sorry to make you wade through all that. Notice how we've gone from "perception bias" to "factual bias," with Peck trying to prove the issue of global warming is somehow settled.
Many newspapers and other media feel compelled to include these minority political views in reports on global warming.
Chris, it's called "the need for balance." It was pioneered by newspapers trying to prove they weren't biased by interviewing "both" sides of any issue, regardless of whether there might be more than one side or whether one side is even worth hearing or not. It's a reflex these days, and not an effort to be truly fair and balanced. That's why so many stories now appear in print with "We were unable to contact so-and-so to comment on this story." They are in a rush to print, even to the point of not running the story until the "other side" has their say.
That is a kind of informational bias. To offer equal weight to the scientific record and the political doubt, in fact, creates bias. These two views on global warming are not equal. One has the weight of decades of research behind it; the other has the weight of a political agenda holding it up.

Yet a study in 2003 of news accounts of global climate change published in major newspapers in this country found that one-third of all news stories presented the science and the political posturing against global warming as equally supported explanations of what is happening in our world.

Is that fair and balanced reporting, to insert doubt about global warming by quoting the politicians who want to deny the science?
And yet newspapers every day, including the CA, run stories on the latest report from this or that study, regardless of what it contradicts or what it really might mean. How many reporters even have the basic knowledge of science and the scientific method to understand what they are covering?
No. The constant reference to ''the other side'' of global warming clouds the issue and makes it much more difficult for citizens to understand what needs to be done to preserve our lifestyle and save the world.
Again, notice how Peck's shifted his focus? We aren't talking -- haven't been for many paragraphs now -- bias, but poor newspaper writing and bad editorial practices.
Journalists must wrestle with similar kinds of informational bias issues when reporting on everything from evolution to vaccinating children against childhood diseases.
And they do so with little to no understanding of the science involved or the issues that provide context for that science. Again, notice how we're still not talking about the Commercial Appeal and what it writes, but on wire stories they pick up from other sources. And run uncritically every day.
Simply giving "the other side" a say in a news account doesn't necessarily provide balance or a true picture of an event or a debate.
Great example: the kerfuffle involving County Commissioner Walter Bailey and renaming or rebuilding three Confederate-honoring City parks. There is a lot of history and detail involving those parks, why they were created and named, the social climate of when these actions were taken, what codicils and laws allow, and the people or events being honored. There is also a lot about Bailey and why he has chosen to champion this issue over many others. None of it comes into the reporting, nor does the paper make a point of presenting stories that are compilations of historical fact or contemporaneous reporting.

What do we get? Guest columns written by self-interested parties in a "both sides" format that is precisely what Peck is criticising. In other words, he practices what he criticises!

Or take City and County budget issues, the kind of reporting over which Peck has direct control. The Commercial Appeal has never, to my knowledge, printed any examination of the details of the way City or County government is set up, nor of the details of the budgets themselves. What we do get is, TA-DAA!, a summation of events with "he said - she said" comments attached, in reaction to events. No pro-active examinations here.
The public seems schizophrenic about the issue of "giving the other side" versus "giving us the best facts" that can be learned.
Ahhhh, and now it's our fault for being "schizophrenic." Peck started with our complaints, briefly tossed them around before going in-depth into something he has no control over and isn't related to Memphis reader concerns, before coming back to the original complaints and finding them our fault. Thanks!
When the media didn't dig more deeply into the cooked books of Enron or WorldCom, for example, critics said the reporters failed to get to the bottom of a story. What we did do, however, was ''report both sides,'' which in the case of Enron and WorldCom meant regurgitating the rosy forecasts of those companies' fabulous business successes.
Ah, Chris. Again, you don't have the resources to investigate those stories.

But, in thsoe stories you could be investigating -- locally -- your paper again falls down. I cannot recall any story about wrongdoing at a local company that was initiated by research and investigation by the paper's reporters. I do know that the "new" CA has lots and lots of friendly, fawning stories about Memphis business.

Take FedEx, for one example. I have heard countless stories from folks who work there about the kinds of abuse the company dishes out to employees it wants to terminate, but cannot fire. Ugly, ugly stuff. Yet the paper, which theoretically has the resources and weight to investigate, has never written anything. Or take their stories on "predatory lending" which attacked the people who meet a need for small, short-term loans. Did the paper ever turn its light on the reasons these lenders exist, which is that large banks refuse to serve them? Any light shined on the big banks, asking them to explain themselves?
My hope is that the role of the media as watchdogs, diggers and skeptics who ask tough questions will be a role that survives in this nation and is valued.

All of us need good information to lead informed lives. The media, at their best, can get us what we need.
And no answer to the original question about bias! What he does manage to do is to make the press look like heroes while dodging real questions.

The whole canard about "real information" is a howler. How much of the "news" in Peck's Commercial Appeal is important and vital to our lives? Comics? Sports? How much of the important activities in our community, the actions of the few which will impact the lives of the many, doesn't get mentioned in the daily paper? How many important investigations were never launched?

Quit patting your own back, Peck. You just keep pressing down on the target taped to your shirt.
New Day or New Jack City?


The reports are coming in from Saturday's Shelby County Democratic Party convention and the news is mixed. Bad for Harold Ford, maybe bad for the Democrats in the longer term, good for Memphis Mayor Herenton, and possibly good for the Democrats down the road.

The best coverage comes from Jackson Baker in the Memphis Flyer. He certainly gives us the most detail. Democratic activist and Convention Coalition member LeftWing Cracker offers quite a bit more. Thaddeus Matthews chimes in too. The Commercial Appeal has a perfunctory summation that focuses more on the past than on the convention.

What was missing, and I would like to have read, is new Chairman Matt Kuhn's background, relationships and alliances. He wasn't the candidate of the Convention Coalition, but of the Herenton crowd. He's been around. Who are his former allies, his former candidates and his recent friends? What does he really bring with him? Will he act as the agent of change the CC wants, or to smother their efforts to serve the Herenton/Chism/Carson bloc?

My take as an outsider is that Mayor Herenton is solidifying his hold on the party. The Convention Coalition folks got their success only because Sidney Chism, Herenton's man, helped them. Do not doubt who will find himself in the driver's seat when the dust settles and things get back to business. While Baker reports the general unhappiness of the Ford faction, there seems to be no unhappiness with the Herenton people mentioned. That says something.

Baker notes, and so do commenters at LeftWing Cracker's blog, that the new Executive Committee of the SCDP is majority white ("...for the first time in decades," is Baker's formulation) as is the party Chair. This change will not be lost on black Memphis and will become a source of resentment and conspiracy. Listen to WDIA next week and see if the theme doesn't emerge that "white folks had to rescue the party from the corrupt black folks." Whatever the Convention Coalition's intention, that's the perception that will come about. I suspect, over time, the silent network of black racism will go to work and the CC folks will one day discover that they are no longer part of the decision-making process.

Harold Ford has just watched his race for the Senate get harder still. Even with the hardball (or dirty, depending on your affiliation) tactics of Upton and the Ford crowd, he lost pretty resoundingly. Heck, he couldn't even be bothered to attend the convention, which any politics watcher would say was a must-attend photo op and alliance building event. Rosalind Kurita, Ford's primary opponent, managed to be there, and she has no irons in this fire! Bad choice on Ford's part and this will certainly be used against him as the primary season rolls along. "If his home base won't support him, why should we?"

The whole Ford machine seems to be truly crumbling. The Commercial Appeal, in a separate article, even feels the need to point it out, though it can be fairly argued that their support for Herenton clouds their view. But when the family pins hopes on also-rans like Ophelia, trouble has come to River City.

On the gripping hand (ie. the third hand; it's a Larry Niven joke), the infusion of vitalising energy will help the party rebuild, provided that the CC doesn't find itself co-opted or racial animosity opens new rifts. For the Democrats that's a good thing. But, again, there's a lot of money (above and below the table) at stake here, a lot of players with their hands in the pot or trying to snatch their share, and some very profitable relationships being threatened. Never underestimate the willingness of the greedy to do what must be done to protect their money. Numbers don't always overwhelm corrupt leadership, especially when some of your allies are part of the corruption.

It depends on what happens with the ongoing Tennessee Waltz, the shadow that only lengthens and never retreats. If the indictees find themselves in court next year near election time, it will hurt the Democrats. If more indictments come down, and it hits Memphis & Shelby County as expected, it may cripple the Democrats. Notice some of the names not mentioned in any reports and their implication in future possible indictments.

Certainly the Republicans are behaving as though it will be a new season. They've latched onto the State Senate District 29 race like they think they can win that longshot.

Interesting days continue.

[Media criticism digression] I was amused to read the following in Jackson Baker's report:
Here are a few of the factors that, by the testimony of some of those voting for Kuhn on Saturday, led to defeat for Rep. Ford’s chairmanship candidate, the mild-mannered and generally well-liked Cocke, and, indirectly, for the congressman himself:

*Dissatisfaction with Ford’s increasingly conservative voting record and rightward-tilting campaign strategy. The two groups making up the Coalition are, in the long-accepted vernacular, “yellow-dog” Democrats, convinced that the chief cause of the party’s electoral reverses in recent years has been the accommodationist politics of over-cautious Democrats.
Notice there are no "that they say" or "referred to by opponents" or "some of those present" phrases here. Reporters and columnists (most definitely including Baker) use those kinds of distancing phrases to take the sting out of someone's positions or statements; it's a defanging technique. No "defanging" of criticism against Ford here; no sir. It's a reasonable assumption that Baker agrees with them.[End digression]

UPDATE MONDAY MORNING Blogger Memphis Blue comes out of hiatus to rail passionately about some of the points made above. I still think that for all the revitalising energy there is a new tension added to the local party's top layer that's going to have bad side effects.
Right Idea, Wrong Questions


This WMC/5 news story points out that many are critical of the new developments happening on the former grounds of housing projects downtown. The reporter talks with the Mayor and some officials, but not with the folks doing the questioning, so the story is incomplete.

What should be asked of the these public housing rehabs is pretty simple: How many public housing units were there orginally? How many are there now? Are any of the new units non-public housing apartments? What was the old cost range for the units? What is the new cost range?

Ask those questions and I suspect you'll have your story.
Once Again: Sizzle, No Steak


Although he tantalizes with hints of untold tales of corruption, the Commercial Appeal's Marc Perrusquia fails to deliver. What he does give is an excellent primer on the Juvenile Court Clerk's office scandal of a couple of years ago, and how it feeds into the Tennessee Waltz scandal.

Once again, Tim Willis is the connection. Perrrusquia also hints around that more indictments are coming down. The West Tennessee District Attorney's office is awfully slow-moving on this; the whole investigation was kicked off in 2002 and only resulted in indictments three years later. Heaven know how much longer new indictments developed from Catron, Willis, etc., will take.
Language Instruction


Bruce at Return of the Mountain Tortoise wonders: "Why doesn't my school teach Mandarin Chinese?" He provides numbers and some experiences. It's a good question and Bruce shows why.

Saturday, July 23, 2005

I Need Your Help


OK, I'll admit it (again). I watch my referrer logs sometimes. Once in a while, some post here gets picked up by another blog and I like to give shoutbacks in the linked post.

I've noticed in the past couple of days that I'm getting a regular flow of people from my domain main page. There's nothing there! It's a static page on a largely moribund site. (OK, it's pinin' for the fjords. It's singing in the bleedin' celestial choir.)

So, if you're someone coming from there, can you leave an anonymous comment as to why, when you could just bookmark this page? Sorry to ask, but I'm curious.
Cameron's Blog


Regular readers know that I'm somewhat of a fan of WPTY/24 news anchor Cameron Harper. He's willing to express opinions and seems to understand that his job is serving the public. Cameron famously interviewed an empty chair when Mayor Herenton refused to participate in WPTY's Hurricane Elvis retrospective last year. He's been the only person willing to call Mayor Herenton on his behavior, in the famous incident where he asked the Mayor if he really would resign if it helped his plans. Very briefly, we saw a change in the local media's treatment of the Mayor, but since then things have sunk back down to the "same old, same old." Herenton has erected further walls between himself and the media and we the public are stuck with a press pool to craven to do anything about it.

Cameron, grab another mike and have another go, would ya?

Anyway, Cameron has been blogging for a while now. It's a company blog, so there's only so much he can say before he threatens his job, but he's still expressing opinion and giving a back-stage view of news production. I enjoy reading it in the same way I enjoy reading Darrell Phillips' and Peggy Philips' blogs.

I've been hoping we'd see an entry about what happened last week, where Cameron called the subject of one story a "fool" and a "chump" on air. I missed that newscast, but it sounds like classic Cameron. Nothing so far, but who knows?

I'll leave you with this bit of Cameron, talking about City Councillor Jack Sammons, talking about City Hall car allowances:
Sammons calls the car allowances “a minnow.” A minnow here… a minnow there, and pretty soon you’re talking about one fat catfish.
So fire up the grill, Cameron, and get roasting!
Antici-- pation


Uh oh. Something's up over at Fishkite. Keep your eye on it about mid-week.
Fleming's Days May be Numbered


Good news, I think, about the Memphis talk radio scene, as Leon Gray will be hosting his own show from 4 - 7PM, weekdays, on the Air America affiliate, AM680 WWTQ.

Mike Fleming, over at AM 600 in the same time slot, publicly couldn't care less, but I think privately must be worried. Mike long ago passed from talk radio into parody. I force myself to catch the first 10 or fifteen minutes (which is about 25 minutes in real time, what with all the ads and promos and suchlike) just to see if he has important local stuff. Nine times out of ten, he's playing "me too!" with the national story of the day, and badly. I'm told he sometimes has good stuff later in the show, but I really don't have the stomach to listen that long.

Fleming can't do think-on-your-feet, intelligent analysis and so goes with hot-button-pushing topics. He doesn't let his callers have their time, but will mostly cut them off, finish their thoughts for them or just pass on to the next call or topic or whatever. You can just about predict what he'll say because he's simplistic and sticks to the same topics over and over and over. And over.

That's why, even if he is a lefty-liberal, I welcome Leon Gray. Any option is likely to be a better option than Fleming. Provided Gray can let his callers talk and can provide some intelligent thoughts, I'll give him a listen. I suspect his first few days will be filled with "Finally, a show I can listen to" calls, but I'll give it a shot.

I'll even recommend you do, too.

Friday, July 22, 2005

Hurricane Elvis


Blogcritics.org: Hurricane Elvis This is a repost of an entry I made one year ago today, the anniversary of Hurricane Elvis in Memphis.

=== === ===

One year ago today -- Tuesday, July 22, 2003 -- a sudden storm with 100 mile an hour winds struck Memphis, Tennessee. In less than thirty minutes, a major metropolis was wrecked, swept from the map. America never knew.

I woke up that day around 5:30, turning on the morning news to see how the weather was going to be. Radar was showing a small, strong cell over northeast Arkansas heading to Memphis. It looked bad, but there were no warnings yet. I decided to haul ass, get dressed and out the door, and try to beat the storm.

I walk to work. That morning, I swung by the Rite Aid on Union. The sky was clouding up quickly; no sunrise today. By the time I left the Rite Aid, there was a light sprinkle starting and the sky was pitch black. The time was just after 6:30. In the short distance down the block from Union to Madison, the sky opened up, dumping a torrent of water. Standing at the corner, I discovered I could barely see a block down the road. The rain and wind was getting worse as I stood there. Braving a couple of oncoming cars, I started across the road and realised my mistake: the wind was so strong that if I fell, I wouldn't get back up in time to get out of traffic!

By the time I made it in the door to work, the rain was falling sideways. Literally. I stood at the window, looking across the parking lot to the apartments on the other side. Water falling on the other side of their roof was being blown over the peak, almost like a horizontal waterfall. The winds were still picking up.

Then the power went out. I got out my portable radio and tuned to WREC, AM600. They were reporting a major storm was sweeping through the city. Well, that was obvious, as the winds were shaking the building of the restaurant I worked in! I had started a bit of opening, but once the power went out, I quit, not knowing how long power would remain out. Little did I know....

The radio kept repeating the storm warning, and reporters were calling in from wherever they were with stories of downed trees, blocked roads and damaged homes. It kept looking worse and worse. The rains eventually slowed down, so I went out to Madison to see what it looked like.

It was awful. Across the street, an old oak was down, snapped at the base, lying on Madison. Looking back to the west, I could see another, huge oak was down across from Zinnie's. Limbs and leaves were everwhere. There was a growing sense that something terrible had happened.

I had a feeling that it would be quite a while before we got power, after lunch at least, so I made sure all the coolers and walk-ins stayed closed, to protect the food for as long as possible. I secured a few other things around the store, then dragged a chair to the door on Madison, with the radio in one ear. Reports were still rolling in and it was bad. Very, very bad.

The first amazing thing was how many folks came out within an hour or so of the storm. I have never seen so many pedestrians on Madison! People were out walking around, inspecting the damage. I got stories from them about trees down on other streets and reports of massive trees down all around the city, blocking Poplar even. We shared whatever news we had, trying to figure out what was going on.

I watched a man walking by the apartments across the street as he climbed up the concrete patios to try all the doors and windows he could reach. He knew I was watching, but kept it up anyway. There weren't any openings, so he continued on.

The phones were out, but I eventually figured out that it was because of the base unit not having power, and not the phone lines. We didn't have a spare that wasn't a mobile, so I had to wait to go back home -- by now I was worrying about damage on my street. There's a hundred-plus foot oak across the street from my building and a two-trunked birch that grew right over the roofline.

After a while of watching the tourists, collecting and swapping stories, listening to the news, and wondering what was next, my buddy Amanda came by. She lives nearby and decided to check in with me. She told me there was no power anywhere in the area, except a small block down around Anderton's for some reason. She pulled up a chair and we just shot the breeze, discussing what little we knew.

I had decided to stay at the store until one of the managers came by, but by 9:30 no one was there yet. No calls, of course. Finally, another worker swung by, Phil. He had been driving all over the city to see what had happened and he had horror stories of ruined buildings, trees down everywhere, crushed cars, plate glass blown out, power out universally, Union almost undrivable from the debris, etc. I figured I'd take a chance here, so I locked up the store, said good-bye to Amanda and hopped into Phil's car.

First thing, we tried to drive by my apartment. We couldn't turn in at Belvedere and Monroe because of a downed oak behind the First Tennessee ATM kiosk blocking the whole street. I started worrying pretty hard now. But when we got to the other side of the block, my building was just fine! The hundred-plus foot oak still stood proudly.

However.... Another oak in the middle of the block was lying over the street and had crushed a car parked under it. A third oak was down, blocking the drives into another apartment building. Soem of the lesser, but still enormous, trees had broken and hanging limbs. One had fallen over a home and snapped the roof. It was spectacular.

We ran into my boss, who was also out looking at the carnage. I told her what was going on at the store, such as it was, and she told me about the Cooper-Young area where she lives, which was also seriously blocked from tree damage.

Phil and I toured Midtown. It was unbelievable how much tree damage there was and how many stores, homes and businesses were affected. It occured to me that one good side-effect of this storm was how many sick and diseased and dead trees had been exposed, had been brought down. Memphis is one of the greenest cities in America, and proudly so. We have one of the most extensive canopies you'll ever see. However, a lot of folks don't take care of their heritage and today was the day we paid for our negligence.

By now, listening to radio, it was clear that this storm had been something of hurricane strength and that most, if not all, of Memphis had been clobbered. Walloped hard. Huge sections of the city were without power and, because it had been mostly by tree damage, it would be a long time before the trees were removed or pruned, the old lines untangled and new lines could be strung. We were in for a repair and recovery period a lot like the Ice Storm of 1994, where some folks went without heat and electricity for weeks, except that this was summertime in Memphis. Heat and humidity would smother the city after the storm clouds passed and a lot of old and sick folks were going to be in peril.

Let ne detour a bit here. Some things had happened during the initial storm strike that no one knew -- because of the power outage. Some television stations managed to stay on the air with generators, the studios barely lit. Amazingly, both the main AM stations, WREC and WDIA, were still broadcasting and had kicked into emergency mode.

But I heard later that the classic rock station was broadcasting during the initial strike. One of their regular guests was driving down Riverside and called them on-air to describe the incredible, inky black clouds massing over the Arkansas side of the Mississippi River. She was talking as the storm crossed the River, then began to scream. The station broadcast her hollering obsceneties -- f-bombs and J f'n C -- as she thought she was going to die. She described how the storm seemed to pick up speed and power as it crossed into Tennessee and Memphis.

At the studio, walls were shaking violently and glass almost blew out. Cars parked along the street below suffered roof and glass damage from flying limbs. The DJ's kept talking, frightened and fearful of death. Winds in the downtown were estimated at 80 miles per hour, with gusts measured in some spots at over 100 mph. Both of the construction cranes over the FedEx Forum were bent due to the winds and several blocks of the area around Beale Street were abandoned. I happened to catch the staff at the classic rock station on the air later that morning as they were instructed by police to leave their studios. Construction was halted that week as builders tried to figure out how to bring the cranes down safely. The Clear Channel radio stations downtown were forced to move to the WPTY building at Union Extended and Poplar, in extra studios in the basement! But they did stay on the air.

There was a car stopped at Parkway and Summer, waiting for a light as the storm swept in. The woman driver and her passenger missed being killed by a falling oak by a matter of mere inches. Their car was completely crushed from right behind the driver's seat to the rear of the vehicle.

It turns out that this was a "perfect storm." The cell that came in from Arkansas was simply a pop-and-go summer storm, the kind you see all the time in this part of the South. But a rare confluence of conditions right over West Memphis dumped massive new energy into the storm, pushing a lot of warm, moist air into a layer of cold air above. The incoming air turned cold, lost its moisture as sudden rain, then came flowing back down at hurricane speeds.

The storm cut a swathe more than a mile wide from the middle of downtown, across the heart of Midtown, through Parkway Village and on into Mississippi. There were a lot of anecdotal reports of funnel clouds, but none were proven, including one over Poplar and Goodlett. The National Weather Service radar couldn't catch the storm's energies correctly, so there was insufficient understanding of its power until it was far too late. The NWS insists, though, that this was pure straight-line winds; no tornadoes.

It didn't matter. Whatever had hit was equal in effect to a hurricane, and far worse than the Ice Storm of 1994. Power was out everywhere. The airport was closed. (It turns out they had no backup generator! One had to be trucked in. Can you believe that?) Communications were fubar'ed. Roads and streets were impassible across enormous sections of the city. No one had any real idea of the extent of the damage until the next day.

You would think that this would be front page news across the country. Unfortunately for Memphis, this was the day that Uday and Qusay Hussein were almost captured and then killed. They were the news of the day. Also, outside reporters couldn't make it in, due to road blockage and the airport closing. Local stations had trouble getting reports together and getting them out. We were, in a real manner of speaking, cut off and ignored.

People in surrounding communities couldn't believe what had happened, due to the narrow focus of the storm's power. Nothing outside of the short but deadly path was touched. Folks were almost disbelieving of what we were telling them.

So, Memphis fell off the map. By supper time that day, we knew we were deep in it and looking at a long, hard haul. Most of the city was without power, including hospitals and police stations; repairing power lines was going to be a long-term job; same for clearing roads. Phone lines, too, were down all over and some towers had been ruined. We became a post-apocalyptic island of survivors swimming in the middle of a sea of normality. Our city had been blasted back into the first part of the twentieth century, stranded there, and left to fend for herself.

Memphians were stunned later to learn that America didn't know what had happened. We only rated a single paragraph inside the USA Today. The Washington Post got to us a week later. The New York Times didn't report us at all, to my knowledge. Evening news bumped us for the Husseins. We felt shunned and ignored. So when the northeast power outage happened later that year and the New York area lost power for a couple of days, Memphians were angry and amused at the wall-to-wall coverage. It wasn't summer up there, it was fall already. Only a couple of days? What wimps! We didn't get power to most of the city for almost a week and whole areas had to wait nearly three weeks. They got all the press and we were the red-headed step child.

It took Tennessee Governor Phil Bredesen three days to show up and tour the damage, which a lot of folks here remember. Bredesen picked a day when City Mayor Willie Herenton had a campaign fund-raiser scheduled for Little Rock, Arkansas, so Herenton elected to skip the Governor for the fund-raiser. A lot of folks were very angry at the time with Herenton skipping town and that came back to bite him when it turned out that the firm hosting the fund-raiser got some special treatment in the City's billion-dollar bond deal with MLG&W. Herenton's now under Federal investigation for his role in all of that.

It also turns out that I know the city's first storm victim. A homeless guy who lives in the neighborhood, Lee Brown, was sleeping in a box across the street from the Ike's on Union (which, by the way, was destroyed by the storm while churches and other buildings around it survived). The burst of winds grabbed the refrigerator box he was sleeping in and swept it across the street and into Ike's! He ended up with a lot of bad cuts and some back injury, but another business owner happened to see the whole thing and called for an ambulance.

By lunch time that day, it was clear this was a disaster. I finally was able to close up the store and leave after catching some incoming employees wondering if we would open or not. Back home, of course there was no power. I walked around the block, and neighborhood, looking at the carnage. It was impressive. Everyone on the street was out, discussing what we knew and what we'd heard. Folks with cell phones were talking to family and friends, lining up a place to stay where there was still power. I later learned that hotels out in the county and across state and county lines filled up rapidly with the dispossessed.

As evening fell, eeriness set in. The city was preternaturally quiet. No planes, little traffic, at least initially. I was able to walk out into the middle of Union Avenue in evening rush hour and just stand there, not seeing any cars. You could hear sirens from police and ambulance all the time in the distance.

And it was dark. Unbelievably dark. I saw stars in such number and mass as you only see well out in the county, it was that dark. You could see the Milky Way. Standing in the heart of Midtown Memphis, you could see the Milky Way.

It was too humid to stay indoors, so everyone on the street was outside on stoops, stairways, porches up and down the block. We talked, shared food that had to be eaten before it melted or spoiled. An Asian family across the street set up a cookfire in front of their building. You could hear every conversation on the street, it was that quiet.

Foot traffic streamed in and out of the street, folks trying to find some store where they could find beer or snack foods, mostly. The surprising thing was the amount of auto traffic as night set in. I couldn't believe the number of folks out driving around to look at the wreckage. Even though there were no lights on Union, except for the Methodist Hospital sign up on the top of the hill west of us, traffic flowed along anyway. Every once in a while, you could hear the fender bender. We marvelled at the curiousity, and stupidity, of people.

Our street was blocked by stout oak trees on both ends, but people kept turning into the street as though things were normal. We watched and waited for some fool to smack into one of the oaks, and though it was close a time or two, no luck. But the tourism trade was a real surprise.

Mosquitos were the worst of it. They bit and bit, attacked over and over all night. It was unrelenting. Because we needed to open windows to cool our apartments, everyone had stories and bumps to show the next day.

I finally went in just before midnight. I'd tried to interest the folks on the street with looking at the Milky Way, which many had likely never seen in their lives, but there were few takers. I still regret that today, as it was both beautiful and scary. It was something that could only be revealed by the city being so hammered down.

I listened to WREC again. They announced that they were switching to their Nashville affiliate after midnight so they could work on their tower or something. There was something really frightening about listening to far-off Nashville, where the story of our trauma didn't always rate a mention in the news breaks, on a battery-powered AM radio in a powerless apartment in a devastated city. It was at that moment when the enormity of our plight finally settled on me, like waking up to realise you really are stranded on that desert isle with a shattered ship.

My poor cat Bennie deserves a mention. When I first got home that morning she was firmly hidden in her "storm hole" under the kitchen counter. It was some time before she came out, and gingerly at that! That evening, she seemed to sense the strangeness as she mostly stayed inside, or near the front door. Her eyes stayed wide and her ears and whiskers were always at full extension. That night, she slept on the bed with me.

Next morning, I took a cool shower and dressed for work. I carefully checked the frozen stuff, which was nearly salvageable still, and all the refrigerated stuff was still fine. But it was obvious we wouldn't get power anytime soon, so I started making plans to toss the frozen goods. The boss came in and we discussed what to do. She'd heard from our supervisor about plans to transfer food items to the stores in our chain that still had power. The assistant showed up, we tossed out all the spoiled food we found and washed dishes for a while. Then we closed up and went home.

Well, I lucked out. Power came back on later that afternoon! It turns out that most of my street is on the same power circuit as St. Peter's Nursing Home. But not my job. It was two more days before we got power back there. I still went in the mornings to check on things and hang out for a few hours, though. And got paid for all of it. Whee!

So, after learning that most of our frozen and refrigerated goods had been moved earlier on the fourth day, I had to go back and return it all to the freezers that evening when power came back. Turns out most of the stuff had spoiled or melted too much to use anyway. When we finally opened again, we got slammed by folks who needed to eat but didn't have power yet. We did records sales, with a reduced crew.

For the rest of that week, Memphis slowly climbed out of the wreckage. I found that WREC radio was mostly taking a "top down" approach to news. They were reporting offical word from city and government agencies, or taking news from their WPTY television affiliate. It was repetitive and not really helpful, to be honest.

Over on black-operated WDIA, it was a very different story. They had taken a "bottom up" attitude, opening their phone lines to callers. All day long, they fielded news of where to find generators and who was price gouging, where to find ice and water and fans, reminders to check the elderly and infirm, reports of working gas stations, etc. It was community radio of the best sort. It was community survival radio. Almost a week after storm day, they found out about a ten-floor retirement building on Camilla that still didn't have power, where the residents were forced to walk the stairs and spend the day outside in the heat and swelter, and spread the word. They were truly heroes of Memphis for their tireless work in collecting and spreading important information.

The city slowly got back on its feet. Memphis was functioning with some normalcy within about three days, and by the next week was generally working again with some large pockets still hurting, like a patient out of bed and on crutches, but still wobbly. It became something of a game to figure out where power was going to come back, and when it would happen. Jealousy and complaining quickly reappeared, which is always a sign of returning health.

The Commercial Appeal started to run a map after a few days, showing which parts of town were still without power. It ended up taking nearly three weeks to get most of the city restored, though the bulk of power was restored after a week. It was amazing to hear the number of people fussing on the radio about still being out of power, only a few days or a week after the storm, and calling MLG&W every name under the sun. People can be so short-sighted and selfish sometimes. But they also brought some trouble on themselves when they turned away offers of help from utilities and teams from outside the city; a lot of folks blew up over that, thinking that the pace of recovery was being delayed. The community uproar over MLG&W's perceived failure to quickly handle the power outage eventually led to the firing of the utility President, Herman Morris, a few months later.

The tree damage took many months to clear. Some dead oak parts laid on our street until the Spring of the next year. One guy at the end of the block just left his fallen oak where it lay and let Nature reclaim it on her own schedule. You can still see the trunk stump and root bundle with a thin coating of dirt and weeds today, across from Sekisui, laid open to the sky.

Hurricane Elvis, as the storm was quickly dubbed, left a mark on the city. You can still find tree and building damage all over the place, a year later. Ike's on Union is still closed. City disaster awareness plans have been re-evaluated. People are more aware of storm cells now; television weather teams are more likely to jump to wall-to-wall coverage during strong storms.

But by and large, we've returned to all the old patterns. Politics is worse than ever here. Racial tensions flared up during recovery -- some folks claimed that "white neighborhoods" got power before "black" areas -- and haven't improved much as they've cooled. The storm is still remembered and talked about, everyone has their stories, but the wind-knocked-out-of-sails feeling has passed.

WPTY, ABC 24, is doing a television special on the storm Thursday night at 7PM. I'm looking forward to it, as I didn't get to see some of the storm onset and immediate aftermath footage. Some of the other news programs will be doing retrospectives during their programming.

I can still recall my feelings of wonder that first night. It was very much like so many of those end-of-the-world movies, lying in bed in the middle of a dead city worrying about how we'd make our way back. Would we make our way back? Pitch dark, deathly quiet, huge shadowed blocks on the horizon from darkened buildings, no planes overhead, tinny radio alternating between normal programming and news of the devastation, only the occasional car and siren telling you that there was still a world out there. It was truthfully one of the spookiest feelings I've known.
Another Sign of the Coming Apocalypse


Birds in Germany are adapting to their environment is bizarre ways.
GERMAN ORNITHOLOGISTS fear that birds in that country have started to imitate the ring tones.

Richard Schneider of the NABU bird conservation centre near the university city of Tuebingen said that the birds have an uncanny ability to mimic ring tones and are suddenly doing so.

The worst offenders are the jackdaws, starlings and jays who seemed to be doing it to wind up bird watchers.

Apparently they see bird watchers, with their maps on strings around their necks and binoculars, and watch them scrabble for their mobiles, with a cunningly mimicked call. Schneider said the phenomenon was that these birds were increasingly common in German cities and were adapting to their environment -- which includes ring tones.
Birds are evil. I watched one last week (brown with a broad white stripe across the edge of the wing) toying with a squirrel. It would swoop across the yard, in a dive-bomb maneuver; then it began to hover over the terrified squirrel and try to snatch at it. Evil.

Hat tip to Zgeek. "We put the M in stupid." WARNING! Some images on the site aren't work safe.
Humor of the Day


What if World War II had been a Real Time Simulation game. What would the chat-room have looked like?
*Hitler[AoE] has been eliminated.*
benny~tow: OMG u noob you killed yourself
Eisenhower: ROFLOLOLOL
Stalin: OMG LMAO!
Hitler[AoE]: WTF i didnt click there omg this game blows
*Hitler[AoE] has left the game*
paTTon: hahahhah
T0J0: WTF my teammates are n00bs
Now you know.

WARNING! LANGUAGE ALERT! POSSIBLY NOT WORK SAFE!